This book may not be "for everyone But if you are a lover of words and in particular the rich "everyone But if you are a lover of words and in particular the rich 19th Century literary and often poetic style of Edgar Allan Poe this book is a treat Yes it s a mystery with multiple ruesome and bloody deaths and murders at its heart but than that it s an exploration of complex and dark characters human beingsand exploration of the darkside of the psyche The book has a slow pace almost measured and it takes its time developing the strands of a complex plot and subplot If you are on the impatient side you may find yourself occasionally wishing that Mr Bayard would speed things up But the ood news is when you reach the ending
the multiple strands of the complex and dark web of characters and motivations that Louis Bayard has wovenpay off supremely in multiple strands of the complex and dark web of characters and motivations that Louis Bayard has wovenpay off supremely in surprising and deeply satisfying ways Wihtout iving anything awaythis is a book which you have to read literally until the last chapter and the last page and the last linesto truly appreciate Also it helps to have some knowledge of Poe s writings and work because many of the images scenes and moments which Bayard invents presage some of the darker and memorable moments of Poe s future masterworks of the macabre All in all a deeply satisfying novel And Louis Bayard if you are listeningmy hat is off to you sirthank you When retired constable Gus Landor is summoned out of his upstate New York retirement to investigate a strange death at the not yet permanent West Point he encounters a charismatic brilliant cadet named Edgar Allen Poe The two team up to solve the mystery using the techniues the estimable Mr Poe would apply in helping establish the murder mystery Biomedical Informatics genre Bayard is up to his usual tricks here delving into literary history for ch The Pale Blue Eye by Louis Bayard is like the writings of one of his characters a tale of mystery and imagination Set at West Point in the 19th Century the novel has all the flavor and ambiance befitting such a setting I love reading books that fictionalize real people Bayard fictionalizes the leadership of West Point at that time as well as one of the most eccentric writers in American historyThe chief investigator of this mysterydetective novel enlists one Cadet Edgar Allen Poe to assist him in his investigation Bayard brings Poe to life to areater extent than he does with any of his other characters Reading the chapters of Poe s reports to Gus Landor the chief investigator of this creepy mysterious case I couldn t help but think that Bayard was having a lot of fun at Poe s expense Bayard does an excellent job of writing Poe s reports to Landor in a tongue in cheek faux PoeEven though the story line has every creepy element conceivable mysterious murders hearts stolen from corpses villains stealing through the darkness in cloaks mysterious strangers disappearing cadets and a The Book of the Honda S2000 graveyard of other things whenever Poe walked off the page it all turned dull Bayard tried to make his protagonist interesting Gus Landor an ex New York detective with a mysterious past I metting tired of using the word mysterious and a bend toward alcoholism leads the investigation Throughout the book Landor looked up at me from the page wanting me to care about him I just couldn t He wasn t likeable or interestingThe Pale Blue Eye feels like a The Story of Rose ONeill guy book If we have Chick Lit here is an example of Dick Lit Distinctive brown cover technical tools on the cover and mahogany tones and pipe smoke throughout All of the women characters are difficult to bring into focus They re silly little things panting for attention and totally oblivious about how trivial they are Even the one with the biggest part to play didn t place a shred of passion on the side of sanity Landor has a cookie cutterirl friend a barmaid who is sleeping with scores of others She is there so that we can have bosoms swaying to the rhythm of pot scrubbing and because we need someone who looks at him with distain and tells him to uit the case because it s killing himAnd then there s the end Don t worry I won t Minibeasts Under a Stone give it away But I will tell you that there s a twist And it s not foreshadowed to an extent where it is warranted In other words Bayard broke the cardinal rule of novel writing I felt manipulated The twist comes from so far out of the court that I was beginning to wonder if I det through the book without having aliens land and tell us they were just there to serve manBut then there s Poe He plays his part unflinchingly The Pale Blue Eye is fun for anyone who wants to be prompted to read a biography about Poe I know I want to et one The details Bayard supplies about him are crisp humorous and fascinating Was he ever a cadet at West Point Did he dedicate his first book of poems to the Academy because he d manipulated the cadets into buying a copy Considering all that the book has iven me to think about I The Prince with the Silver Hand (Tale of the Eternal Champion, guess I mlad I read it But I m even lad that it s over Audio There are many well writ. Bayard reinvigorates historical fiction rendering the 19th century as if he'd witnessed it firsthand He employs words like caoutchouc meerschaums and anapestic as fluently as he uses Got.
Louis Bayard ´ 1 REVIEWOnel Sylvanus Thayer fearing political fallout for the fledging institution "calls in Augustus Landor local resident and former New York City police detective of some renown to investigate hoping to "in Augustus Landor local resident and former New York City police detective of some renown to investigate hoping to the situation under control before Army bureaucrats descend The wily Landor meets and is impressed with an intellectual and keenly observant young cadet Poe of course and reluctantly is ranted permission to have Poe clandestinely assist in the investigation It is a task Poe relishes and rises to with aplomb setting for the stage for a Gothic tale of uncommon depth where opposing images the New York s Hudson Valley s majestic splendor and unrelenting desolation provide the perfect backdrop to Bayard s chameleon prose But there is so much to The Pale Blue Eye than the author s clever spins on Poe Doyle and Washington Irving This is an extensively researched labor of love with well drawn characters an atmosphere as moody as the reclusive Poe and an illuminating slice of American culture in 1830 But most of all it is simply a terrific story one that takes twists and turns along the way and just when you think you ve The Keys To The House, Tree, And Person got it figured out turns around and jars you out of any self congratulating complacency like West Point s reveille on those cold and damp winter mornings of the Hudson heights Unlike Matthew Pearl s excellent but wordy The Poe Shadow The Pale Blue Eye moves uickly dodging and weaving through deepening depravity to a climax as shocking and unexpected as anything Hitchcock has rendered If I had a complaint it is Bayard s subtle but condescending view of the cadets and administration of West Point an unnecessary and unfair slight to the fine men and women of this venerable institution but only a minor distraction not sufficient to curb my enthusiasm for this refreshingly original yarn In short one of those rare books that will keep you turning the pages way past the time you know you should be asleep a true triumph of fiction in a historical setting Well done Mr Bayard You can t swing a dead cat these days without hitting a book with historical characters in a fictional setting And I swing a lot of dead cats believe meWhen it s done well though who cares how many of them there are And Louis Bayard does it well Fresh off his fine Mr Timothy his look at Dickens Tiny Tim as an adult OK so Tiny Tim wasn t historical but youet the idea Bayard threw Edgar Allan Poe into a novel No he s not the first or last to do this but The Pale Blue Eye which of course takes its name from a Poe poem also is a successWhereas Mr Timothy was only superficially connected to A Christmas Carol really it could have been any down on his luck Englishman of the time The Pale Blue Eye is full on Poe circa 1830 when he was a cadet at West Point Former cop Gus Landor is called in to solve the death a hanging suicide murder and subseuent de hearting disheartening OK he had his heart torn out of a West Pointer Before long Landor meets the then unknown Poe is intrigued and enlists his aid in solving the crime More people die Poe falls for the daughter of the West Point doctor the relationship between Landor and the not always truthful Poe takes some twists and turns and the crime doesn t Unjust Deserts get much closer to being solved Weet flashes of EAP s poetry And about 10 percent of the novel is told from Poe s point of view via his written dispatches to Landor who s otherwise the first person voice here Bayard handles these sections well they sound authenticMr Timothy sure was fun Bayard has a knack for George V. Higgins grimly humorous protagonists The Pale Blue Eye starts out in a similar vein until you almostet tired of Landor s whimsy But the tone changes Black Brothers, Inc. gets serious and we re smack in the middle of strangeoings on Yeah the West Point powers that be do seem awfully patient as Landor s investigation plods on than a month oh wellBayard s Poe book 35 stars isn t uite as fun or as ood as his Tiny Tim book but it is strong and I hope he keeps stories like these coming He s a ood one I find myself on a Louis Bayard binge I uite enjoyed The Black Tower and just finished this one and was impressed as well In the historical fiction crime mystery Daddy Daughter Incest 2 Series Bundle genre which I often find myselfravitating towards a la Matthew Pearl and Caleb Carr these are excellent The Pale Blue Eye includes a young Edgar Allen Poe during his short time at West Point Always read to the very last page with Bayard Gorgeous heart breaking writingcheckAn unreliable but completely sympathetic protagonist with Holmesein deductive skills a tragic backstory AND sex appealcheckAn expertly described setting whose real history was revealed as a enuine and vital part of the story that I found endlessly fascinating despite having zero interest in learning anything about it before nowcheckA truly unlikely Watson drawn from real life with such care I had to remind myself I wasn t reading nonfictioncheckDevil worshipcheckI mean what can a irl ask for. T But none of it seems musty Bayard does what all those ads for historical tourist destinations promise as Landor says at death's door the past comes on with all the force of the present. Ten reviews of this book on Goodreads I
reading reviews and seeing why people liked this book I just didn t like it that well Ithe reviews and seeing why people liked this book I just didn t like it that well I t read a lot of Edgar Allen Poe and although I understand that the language in this book was supposed to be indicative of his style it was just too wordy and flowery for me It dragged in too many places and the fun parts were few and far between It would have been better for me had it all been like this Oh Leah let me play Screamed Mrs Maruis Leah needed no injunction than that uit her place at the piano and hied herself straight to the back of the column wrapped her hands around Artemis waist and set to swaying Mrs Maruis proudly perched on the piano bench pounded out a dance tune recently imported from "Vienna Playing It Double "playing it double with an almost frightening virtuosity And there I sat smiling coatless and damp asking myself Which of the people in this room just tried to kill meBecause Poe was a real person I expected this to be a historical novel but the details of his life his words and his character traits the story taking place when he is a young man were completely fabricated by the author Even the crux of the story a murder at West Point Academy never happened I like a little history with my history whenever possible If you like 18th and 19th century literature the This Many Miles From Desire gothicenre in eneral or are a big fan of Poe read on This whodunnit didn t really do it for me 19th Century West PointWonderful characters and creative story that involves cadets one missing and then found dead with hearts cut out On the first instance Mr Landor a retired constable who lived close by was recruited by the academy to solve the death suicide or murder Sylvanus Thayer had just asked me to save the honor of the US Military Academy by once taking up the work I had sworn off for Sermons Not Spoken goodLandor asks permission to have inside help and speaks with candidates Among them Edgar Poe I believe it is incumbent upon me and the honor of this institution to divulge some of the conclusions which I have reached regarding l affaire Fry He threw back his head as he said it I remember thinking that anyone who used a phrase like l affaire Fry should probably throw back his head Exactly like thatPoe and Landor make uite the interesting team conducting investigations in the dark and on the uiet Poe falls in love with a young woman sister to one of the individuals under suspicion Both Poe and Landor discover separately she is subject to the falling disease Her father is the resident physician for the academy but is a weak man subject to whims of his wife son and daughterTo say could spoil the plot I learned of this writer from someone s review on of a Stephen Gallagher book a writer I enjoy Mystery This wasoing to Julia get four stars right up until twenty pages from the end at which point it seriously pissed me offAugustus Landor retired New York constable recounts his involvement in a murder investigation that takes place at West Point in 1830 Guest starring Edgar Allan Poe I thoroughly enjoyed the first 387 pages of this novel It s a nice little mystery with a hint of the supernatural and lots of cold West Point atmosphere Bayard is an engaging writer His prose is clear and simple with freuent moments of wonderfulness and the story progresses at aood clip revealing clues and hidden allegiances as it builds up a Dancing with Fireflies (Chapel Springs, great friendship between Landor and Poe Poe actually did spend a few months as a West Point cadet that much is true but his character could have been any pale self aggrandizing heartbroken slacker intellectual there s really nothing about the book or Poe that reuires his presence I liked this Poe a lot but beyond the bare details I saw little to connect him to the Poe that history left usOkay so that s the first 387 pages then on page 388 there s a Surprise Twist and Iot all riled up and started accusing Bayard of wasting my time The way the story is written leaves no room for this kind of obfuscation and the narrative doesn t even attempt to justify it It pissed me off and completely took away from my enjoyment of the book I m not against a fabulous surprise ending but this was done badly and with no textual supportThis is etting three stars and a big stink eye Kudos to Louis Bayard for this uniue and cleverly crafted murder mystery set in the early days of The US Military Academy at West Point an unlikely setting but not as unusual as the casting of Cadet Fourth Class Edgar Allan Poe in a lead role Poe indeed attended West Point albeit briefly a historical fact which the talented Bayard uses to full advantage in spinning a tale that apes Poe s macabre eerie surrealist style while at the same time capturing intrigue and enigma that could pass for Arthur Conan Doyle When a cadet is found hanged an apparent suicide But as if that is not enough the corpse is posthumously desecrated with the removal of the young man s heart West Point Superintendent Col. Hic tropes Landor is attacked in the dark woods and in a dark closet Messengers drive phaetons There's black magic phrenology a profusion of hosts even a boat trip through torch lit mis.